Wow,how sad that Kevin Roberts readily admitted what his sister testified to in court-that this is merely a vendetta against his neighbors because he is miserable & wants everyone else to be. He really needs psychological help and a new place to live. Something tells me he's not going to let this go until he has a breakdown/meltdown & I sure hope no one gets hurt further as a result of his behavior. It's got to be horrible to live in a neighborhood with someone so spiteful for no good reason. May God have mercy on you Kevin & I hope you find some peace within yourself to heal your past grievances & find some joy in your life.

Roberts' other sister, Donna Medlin, testified on Hoag's behalf, saying her brother vowed to live in the Crown Point Parkway house, which originally belonged to their father, for the rest of his life "just so he can make the neighbors' lives as miserable as possible."

Kevin Roberts acknowledged that is true.

Very sad that Kevin has chosen making "the neighbors' lives as miserable as possible" as his apparent #1 goal in life. It also sounds a little scary - like someone who could "go postal". I think he needs help to get past this or he will die a very unhappy man. And, the best thing for him to do is contact a realtor and move - for his own peace of mind and those on the street.
It also doesn't sound like there was any damage at all. Just complaining about some debris from the fireworks. But, how much could there have been? I hope he had pictures. If not, I would tend to doubt the amount of debris he was claiming, as this guy was quick to video the fireworks being set off so he definitely would be one to take pictures of ANY little debris in his yard.
And, I'm having a hard time imagining people who come out to view Christmas decorations as being a rowdy, swearing, violent crowd.

It's pretty sad that your own sister testifies against you. Mr Robertz needs to get over this and move on.

Oh, and my heart goes out to Cheryl Roberts traumatized dog. If Mr Roberts wins his suit, maybe he will give Cheryl some money so she can take her dog to see a shrink.

I agree I hope no one gets hurt, but I think it is the police and maybe corrupt mayors that allow some folks to ignore laws that are there to protect us. It’s got to be horrible to live in a neighborhood where you can’t even have your family over for a peaceful holiday. Regarding the sisters testimony anyone who would go out of their way to testify against a family member is clearly spiteful, disgruntled and has a vendetta. I hope everyone can each find peace and be respectful of each other.

No wonder the dog was traumatized.

http://dunheimerphoto.com/wp-content/photos/OsamaRama/reg/110501_trs+CarCrowd.jpg

You see Jean at the end of the day we are a nation of laws. Perhaps Crown Point could separate from the union and form a mobocracy.

Steve AKA Kevin, if you truly desire peace,then end your vendetta. Either move or get some psychological help to understand your need/desire to "punish" others for your own distorted reasons. That is the only way there will be peace. Do you realize how much space that anger takes up & controls your life & how miserable it is making MAINLY YOU. Yes,you see,the others do have lives & go on & you are only a small part of theirs-maybe that's what bothers you-you are lonely & hateful and that will only continue unless you move or get the help you so richly need. I pray for you that you face the hurt that is causing this behavior & find a way to come to terms with it. Your neighbors sound like they can be very forgiving people-they have not bashed you or attacked you personally in the media(stating factual truths of events is not bashing),which they could have if they were the awful people you'd like others to believe. They obviously care enough about you & are concerned for your mental health/well being. Please seek out & ask forgiveness or at least help for yourself. You will be very surprised at how compassionate people can be& how direct communication can melt away misunderstandings or hatred. Forgiveness is so healing for both parties-it truly is a gift you give yourself.

I sure hope with all this anger this man has for his neighbors I hope he don't own a gun.,

Wow! There is no other way to write this. “You people are really stupid.” I thought this web site was an open forum to post opinions, but now I see it is just a lynch mob wanting to persecute a neighbor for trying to live in peace and I hope Mr. Roberts does have fire arms to protect himself if needed from the ignorant bully’s that appear to have so much hate towards him.
Signed “Not Mr. Roberts”

Roberts is seeking $3,000 from Hoag, alleging the fireworks have damaged his property and that his sister, Cheryl, was harassed and heckled when she tried to drive through the crowd two years ago. so his submitted a ESTIMATE for 305 to clean up the debries which leaves 2700 for what??? it cant be for pain and suffering because he admitted that he is going out of his way to make life miserable for his neighbors >>>>> so he wants 2700 because his plan did not work since his neighbors are still happy

Steve, I am proud of you and your comments. I wonder how many of these complainers actually live on that street. This has gotten well out-of-hand. People making comments about "having to get mental help", "ask forgiveness", etc. Forgiveness for what? Folks, this man/family have the right to disagree and complain if he wants. He is an American and a home owner, he has rights.
I will pray for all you "haters", tonight.

Wow! There are some ignorant comments posted here. I thought this web site was an open forum to post opinions, but now I see it is just a lynch mob wanting to persecute a neighbor for trying to live in peace. I hope Mr. Roberts does have a means to protect himself if needed from the ignorant bully’s that appear to be above the law and have so much hate towards him.
Signed “Not Mr. Roberts”

Is Kevin angry @ everyone? Or just a certain few?

Let’s put our emotions aside for a moment. It is against Ohio law for an individual who does not posses a license issued by the State Fire Marshal to set them off. Individuals who violate the fireworks law face first-degree misdemeanor criminal penalties.A first time offender can be sentenced to up to six months in jail and also fined up to $1,000.Subsequent conviction is a fifth-degree felony potentially punishable by a prison term of up to one year. I do not believe Mr. Hoag and possibly others would enjoy that. Even the most experienced licensed pyrotechnic display companies have experienced various degrees of failures during their events. Here are some facts.Number of injuries caused by fireworks in 2010 (8,600) Number of fires caused by fireworks in 2009 (18,000) Amount of direct property loss caused by fireworks in 2009 ($38 million). GO SEE
http://www.cpsc.gov//PageFiles/108534/2011fwreport.pdf
http://www.usfa.fema.gov/citizens/focus/fireworks.shtm
https://www.ohiobar.org/forpublic/resources/lawyoucanuse/pages/lawyoucanuse-521.aspx
http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/3743
Hopefully this has educated those city officials who may have been involved with providing Mr. Hoag verbal permission to conduct his firework display.Keep in mind we all have a right to live in a neighborhood free from illegal activity. It is the responsibility of our city officials to ensure that this is the case to the maximum extent possible.Ignorance of a law is not an excuse for violating it.

Debbie, Kevin, Steve, et al. -
All of us on the outside looking in can see that this vendetta has gone on long enough, whatever it is. You may never get the resolution or satisfaction that you desire - but you need to accept that. To carry it on like this for so long and any longer is so childish and very damaging to ones mentality. Life goes on and apparently has for everyone but those in that Roberts family. But to resort to cutting electric lines and wanting to live in a house to just make peoples lives miserable is pathetic, and again, scary. Get some help. Yes, he does need it, IMO. Why would anyone come to a different conclusion?

I hope the police are looking out for this James Murphy (AKA Adolf Hitler) that wants to vandalize houses with eggs

If someone continued to break the law repeatedly, I would want to make their life miserable by calling the police. Oh wait, he tried that.

Debbie (AKA Cheryl) Stay in Garfield Hts. Leave Kevin alone and lets stop this feuding. You are doing nothing but helping fuel the fire. You seem to have a lot of problems of your own.

I will be glad when this is over. every neighborhood always has that neighbor who goes out of his way to complain about silly things, and this Mr Roberts seems to fit that guy well. all of the kind and generous people on the street try to bring joy to as many people as they can, by setting up such beautiful lights spending untold hours and wattage, all the while collecting donations for others.
And what do they get for a thank you, someone who moves in right next door who vowed to make their lives miserable. So thank you Mr Roberts You have brought much embarrassment to our city with your pettiness

One thing Kevin Roberts has done is probably added more traffic to the street - now, for his next Thanksgiving dinner and all holiday season long. People like to see where these disputes take place and where a person lives that they read about.
For sure more people are going to stop and gaze at this guys house and know this is where the Grinch lives. I can see it now, all those fingers pointing out of the car windows as they drive by next year - hey, isn't that where that guy lives who is like the Grinch? Or is it Mr Scrooge? Bah-humbug!!!

I’m taking a break from doing taxes so I will reply only this last time to Lyn and Kim L or others whose comments are not reasoned. I do not wish to attempt having a rational conversation with someone who cannot keep from verbally attacking a person.

My name is indeed Paul and I am not related to Mr. Roberts, either by blood or marriage. My knowledge is based on what I have read, seen on television news, or experienced.

I have presented some rather strong comments based on facts, and have substantiated my comments by providing links, when possible, for people to go look up for themselves. The law is the law. If we elect individuals who will not uphold the laws should they remain in office? No one is above the law.

Mr. Roberts is being persecuted without cause. Has he done anything unlawful? NO and I am not aware of any actions that he has done that are unlawful. He has asked city officials to uphold the law and they refuse to. Obviously, you and others do not care for him. You all should take a lesson from Mr. Hoag. He stated that he likes Mr. Roberts and has no animosity towards him. Why then do you and others?

If you wish to continue, I will be more than happy to answer, but only once you apologize for your verbal attacks to Mr. Roberts, and you present a logical and lucid comment. Also, when time allows me to. Now back to doing taxes!

LOL...AMEN...Kim ...You hit the nail on the head.

Paul-

So, again - WHAT DID THE FIRE CHIEF SAY? You can't make that statement and not back it up. You said you were including him when you were referencing city officials when you said "The city officials are ultimately to blame for their blatant disregard of Ohio law." So, I assume you have first hand knowledge since you reiterated this to make your point, and can now back up this statement. And I'm not talking about after the fact - how is he to issue a permit or give his approval without being asked first?

You wouldn't know what the fire chief knew or not unless you were involved!

As for the nutjob being persecuted - he does have a personality disorder, IMO, that has resulted in this frivolous lawsuit - he admitted he has this obsession with tormenting the people who live on the street. The stuff introduced into evidence about sis not being able to leave and dinner being ruined is laughable and a waste of court time. So, the fallout on him is his own fault. The fireworks part does not belong in small claims court - and you know it by reading the links I gave you, which you later copied in your own comments.

I want to apologize for writing that everyone here is stupid. This is Gods job to judge.
But come on…..This Elmer guy is obviously as dumb as a box of rocks.

I don't know Paul, but his take is pretty much spot on. I recently retired from the Strongsville Fire Dept. after 26+ years. I was following this whole issue out of curiosity, and that led me to call my former co-workers in the fire prevention bureau. Bottom line: the fire department was never officially consulted in regards to this fireworks display. They "unofficially" knew it was going on, but no inquiries regarding a permit were ever made, by either Mr. Hoag or Mayor Perciak. I was told that if formal permission had been requested, it would have been denied. Both the lack of a professional/licensed exihibitor and the proximity to homes in the area would have been major issues. If you don't believe me, please feel free to contact the SFD fire prevention office at 580-3225. My apologies to those guys, but this dis-information needs to be cleared up.

So, if you wish to read between the lines, this part of this story boils down to politics.

Kevin needs to live on an island by himself. He doesn't know how to interact with humans. He doesn't get along with anyone at work either! His goal in life is to make others miserable because he is a miserable person. This is so sad :(

tom m,
Maybe he (Mr Roberts) is so frivolous that he wants restitution for his ink cartridges used for his evidence, probably his VHS tape(s) too, his time to do the clean up, for his sister for her's and her dog's emotional distress. Who knows? Maybe he wants the extra $2695.00 just to teach Dan Hoag a lesson. So sad, to say the least. If Mr Roberts get's even a penny, I will loose my faith in the court system.

I have to admit that this is SO SAD, but amusing, to say the least. Just to see how many alias's Kevin and Cheryl can come up with to side with him.

I think all here who are appalled by Mr.Robert's & his sister's behavior & comments need to realize that we are dealing with some very emotionally disturbed people.Whether or not the magistrate rules that proper protocol was not followed & issues damages to be paid or not,Mr. Roberts & Co.(there are so many "personalities"/aliases of he& his sister supporting each other it's hard to know who is legitimately commenting) will probably see it as a "victory" in their vendetta-for a short while. However,that won't satisfy them for long & they will find something else to make his neighbors miserable,because that appears to be his life's goal.This whole fireworks thing is just the tip of the iceberg in the mind of 2 emotionally disturbed siblings who enable each other.There is obviously underlying pain related to the loss of their father. People should not be joking or calling him names because it may push him to the point of acting out on his mission of hurting others(be it emotionally or physically). The police will not protect the neighbors because until he actually does something that breaks a law(in which case it may sadly be too late) they cannot act. This represents what is wrong in our country in regard to treatment of the mentally ill/disturbed.This is why many recent tragedies happened.People knew there was something wrong w/these people but the laws don't support doing anything about it until what they do is considered a criminal act-and by then it's usually too late.

Nicely done Beverly

OH MY GOD did you see them shooting off those fireworks INSIDE the superdome those dangerous fireworks all those people

Hahahaha elmer!!!! Thats hilarious!!!!
Now let me just say, i lived on crown point all my life. No one was ever in danger, the firewprks were never a problem. Kevins dad was a very nice old man untill about 2001 i believe it was... I was selling cookies and he yelled at me to get off his property and told me the bank was closed... This came from outta no where... He always had been so nice...
But in my opinion, kevins father didnt become that way on his own... I believe kevin rubbed off on him. Kevin has always been crazy and seriously messed up in the head. Atleast for the 23 years ive known him....
But regardless, i think this is all ridiculous and everyone on here whos tryin to make kevin look like a victim... You all are just idiots.

Kevin is no victim-he's one disturbed man & all the aliases he & his sister are posting under prove that. In fact those appear to be the majority,if not all of the posts that "defend" him. Again,I hope that neighbors are being vigilant about recording & reporting his behavior to police.

WOW!!!!!!!Kevin ooooops I mean Paul/Steve OPEN MOUTH INSERT FOOT I recall a previous post here stating someone had pictures of Kevin Roberts years ago participating in the LIGHTING OF THE FIREWORKS DISPLAY. Was KEVIN ROBERTS not participating in an ILLEGAL ACTIVITY??? Where was KEVIN ROBERTS' concern for peoples SAFETY and the LAW back then???? Hmmmm a little hypocritical don't you think??? Can you say V-E-N-D-E-T-T-A!!!! Shame on you Kevin Roberts. A LITTLE EGG ON YOUR FACE MAYBE??

Otis, Now-Now be nice, We all have the choice to change our minds in later life. Tt is hypocritical but most people doing this sort of thing do have a vendetta against others. The question is, what is the next vendetta going to be? I feel for the people living on Crown Point Pkwy., because this nut is not finished.

Careful Elmer. Even if Mr Roberts thinks you are "as dumb as a box of rocks", you just might be his next vendetta. Don't worry I think you are funny!

Thanks Otis, I'll deal with the NUT if it happens....lol

Otis, I'll even go to the Supreme Court if I have to.... lol

has the courts ever ruled on this yet ??? I hope all the generous people who put on the display for all of our enjoyment are not harmed by the deeds of one angry human

No ruling on the case as of 2/13/13. We are still waiting.

Well you are right that this could potentially take a turn for the worse. Especially with this neighbors background. Non of you know the extent of his background. But PLEASE don't let it stop you from seeing the lights. Thanks to the people who visited our street we were able to donate over $4000 to the family of an 11 year old with terminal brain cancer. Unfortunately just over a week ago he lost his battle but the donations possibly lightened the monetary burden his parents are going through.....just a little but at least something.

These people got permission from city officials. Hmmm, go figure. Illegal? Evidently not!

http://fox8.com/2013/02/12/fireworks-mistaken-for-explosions-in-trumbull/

did these two ever go back to court for a decision yet ???

There has been no verdict yet.

Well it's about time!

From Fox 8 News

BEREA, Ohio– A judge has dismissed a man’s claim that his neighbor’s fireworks display ruined his Thanksgiving dinner.

However, the judge did rule that the neighbor must pay the man cleanup costs from the fireworks debris that fell on his property.

Kevin Roberts of Strongsville sued his next door neighbor, Daniel Hoag, after he claims a fireworks display this past Thanksgiving ruined his holiday dinner.

The lawsuit claimed fireworks debris fell on Roberts’ home and yard, and a family member suffered emotional distress from the crowds of people blocking the driveway to watch the display.

Monday, a judge ordered Hoag to pay just more than $300, plus court costs and interest, to the plaintiff for the cleanup costs.

But the judge threw out the claims for emotional distress and spoiling Thanksgiving dinner.

Hoag said he has received a tremendous outpouring of support and donations and the money left over after the settlement will be given to charity.

I believe the court should pay the interest for taking so long to make it's decision.

Make that a turkey dinner at that.