No Decision on Crematory at Jardine's
Planning Commission tables conditional use permit, site plans for cremation equipment
The city Planning Commission has tabled plans for Jardine Funeral Home to add a crematory to its Pearl Road business.
The commission Thursday night delayed requests for a conditional use permit and site plan approval for the property at 15822 Pearl Rd.
Chairman Jeffrey Ice said the commission will "do a little more homework" on the impact of a crematory before deciding.
The issue will come up again at the July 26 meeting.
Some residents have raised concerns about crematories emiting hazardous amounts of mercury into the air.
The mercury comes from fillings in people's teeth, and it's not a new issue -- funeral homes across the country have faced fights to build crematories in recent years.
But at a public hearing Thursday night, no residents spoke against the crematory.
Instead, eight residents, many from Hunting Meadows, stood up and spoke in favor of the project.
"I have absolutely, positively no concerns of any negative things the crematory would bring to Strongsville," said Tom Brubeck, a Jardine's employee who said his Raccoon Trail home is the closest of any house to the site.
"I do not believe they (the Jardines) would do anything to put their children in jeopardy, or mine," said Tom Krebs of Rabbit Run Drive.
Ward 4 Councilman Scott Maloney, who serves on the Planning Commission, said he spent hours researching the subject last weekend and found a study that showed the area around one 40-year-old crematory had 200 times lower mercury levels than what is allowed on a children's playground.
Jason Jardine said the equipment he is buying is a state-of-the-art machine that is designed to run in neighborhoods and emit no smoke or smell. Nearby Wendy's and Burger King produce more emissions into the air, he said.
The equipment would be used only for Jardine clients and could not be rented by other funeral homes.
Jardine said having on-site cremation equipment would ease worries of many distraught families who would now be able to keep their loved ones close to home.
He also said cremation is becoming a more common choice, with about 40 percent of people opting for it.
Jeff
9:57 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
The crematory belongs in an industrial park just as the city of Cleveland requires. How can anyone take the chance of ANY mercury contamination on the children of Strongsville for the almighty dollar? But we now know who! This is crazy. It will be right next to the High School, the bus yard, the post office and the new Giant Eagle. From the information that is out there, the Jardines are not installing scrubbers to make mercury contamination that less likely to happen. If they are going to put the crematory in the center of town, at least spend the money to put the scrubbers in for the safety of the community and especially the children. Come on, do the right thing here Jardines! Don't put money above the healt of the community. This will become an Erin Brockovich story years from now. The Jardines have the chance to do the right thing, install the scrubber or build crematory in the industrial park.
Charles Hoffner
12:23 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Agreed. It will both compromise the value and utilization of the School Boards property. Jardine was behind the scenes in favor of the Giant Eagle fiasco because it would increase "traffic" to the neighborhood. Lived in Hunting Meadows for over 36 years. Where is my newly elected neophyte Schonutt (less) Councilman on this! Come on City of Strongsville, start to talk to the Schools, protect our infrastructure and basic values. Three weeks down the road they will be importing bodies to be disposed of and there is nothing you can do about it! Good luck Strongsville, I just wish we had Wally back!!!
tom m
10:20 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
But at a public hearing Thursday night, no residents spoke against the crematory.
Instead, eight residents, many from Hunting Meadows, stood up and spoke in favor of the project
would these be the same hunting meadows people who the city officials are bending over backwards to please over giant eagles
tom m
10:27 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
And lets look at those who spoke in favor of the plans
Tom Brubeck.........I have absolutely, positively no concerns of any negative things the crematory would bring to Strongsville," said Tom Brubeck, who said his Raccoon Trail home is the closest of any house to the site
now lets look at jardines own website .....
.
My name is Tom Brubeck and I have been a member of the Jardine Staff for ten years. As a Strongsville resident for the past 36 years, Charter member of St. John Neumann Parish, Former Councilman, and licensed realtor with Coldwell Banker in Strongsville, I am very familiar with many of the people who utilize our services.
Jean Williams
12:07 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
great job Tom M
Tom Brennan
5:32 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Don't know if is still the case, but I know that Jason Jardine used to live in Hunting Meadows right behind the driving range / future GE site. Not claiming that means anything, but maybe some "friendly" neighbors were present, in addition to Mr. Brubeck.
lyn
10:53 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
How can Tom Brubeck get up and state that he lives closer to Jardines than anyone else, when the large Hunters Hollow apartment complex is practically adjacent to the Jardines property and Brubeck is way over across Pearl, behind the driving range. And when Giant Eagle is built, the store and towering mound will provide him a nice "shield". Sounds like he was trying to give a nice persuasive argument on behalf of his employer, Jardines, as tom m revealed.
Kim L
11:00 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
Very impressive catch tom m! You even got the editor to change the story to mention that it was employees speaking in favor of the ovens
Debbie Palmer
9:42 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Lyn, just to clarify, Tom Brubeck said his was the closest single-family home. I used "house" in the story to reflect that.
lyn
11:44 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Yes, Debbie you are correct. I did use my own words to show that there are MANY people who live much closer than Tom, rather than quote you. However, Tom is not correct in saying he is the closest, as his home is not the last home on Raccoon bordering the driving range - there are 2 others. He is really stretching his support for this issue when he lives way over there across the street from and behind the driving range. And, they will be behind, out of sight and protected by that tall mound and large Giant Eagle. All those other residents of the apartment complex are closer. As are the residents of Altenheim and all the people who work in the area, 8 hours per day, maybe more. And, the high school is near.
And, did this Tom present himself also as an employee of Jardines at the meeting?
lyn
12:02 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
I can't imagine this will get approved after I heard how some city officials have been concerned about the mercury levels. When there is even a question of safety, regardless of whatever manufacturer assurances may be attached to a product, I would hope that the city would follow through with their "gut" feelings on this project and deny it, at least in this location. Again, why not have the regulations require this type of facility be built in an industrial area. Follow Cleveland's lead, talk to other cities, and find out more before you rubber stamp this project. Why does it need to be built at the current Jardines location? If they are so concerned about taking care of their own clients, they can still build another facility somewhere else close by - Foltz is not that far, and don't we want that area expanded? They should have considered this before acquiring their current property.
Debbie Palmer
12:03 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Lyn, no he didn't. Tom M. pointed it out in his comments.
lyn
12:16 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
Debbie-
Thanks for your reply.
I didn't know if that was all Tom Brubeck said, or if he did go on to reveal his connection. I was hoping he said a little more and gave full disclosure.
sville
11:37 pm on Monday, July 16, 2012
ii